Studia Theologica 2017, 19(4):241-261 | DOI: 10.5507/sth.2017.037

Fr. M. D. Leroy O.P. (1828–1905) – průkopník možnosti katolické recepce evolučního vzniku lidského těla

Ctirad Václav Pospíšil
Katedra systematické teologie
CMTF UP

François Maria Dalmace Leroy O.P. (1828–1905): a Pioneer in the Catholic Acceptance of the Evolutionary Origin of the Human Body

This study presents the life and work of the French Catholic theologian M. D. Leroy (1828–1905) regarding the issue of the evolutionary origin of humans. His book, published in 1891, met with harsh reactions from the side of transformism opponents, after which it was followed by the process of the Sacred Congregation of the Index. The work was condemned and the author was reprimanded. Leroy formally submitted himself to the Congregation’s decision. The implicit dualism was the basic problem of the so-called Mivart thesis. Leroy claims that the human body can be called human, if the body is united with its essential form only, ergo its immortal soul. By means of the evolution, the creator could prepare a certain pre-human species, the substrate of the creation of a human body by the infusion of the immortal soul. The study by Leroy contains a number of new elements: an explanation of the apparently contradictory attitudes of Pope Leo XIII, a reference to the views of the remarkable French apologist F. Duilhé. Although he did not accept Leroy’s point of view, he did take sides on the right for liberal research in this area for Catholic theologians in 1897. There are essential links of the detection in between, as to what was the French and Czech natural science point-of-view in relation to Darwinism at this period. Leroy’s thesis is still relevant as it corrects the implicit dualism in the area of anthropology, which is implicitly presented in the widespread solution of the Catholic world today. The human body, in his view, came into being through evolution and was provided with a human soul at a certain moment.

Vloženo: květen 2017; Přijato: srpen 2017; Zveřejněno: leden 2018


Reference

  1. Archivium Fratrum Praedicatorum, vol. XXXI, 1961.
  2. ARINTERO, JUAN T. GONZÁLES O.P., La Evolución y la mutabilidad de las especies orgánicas, Librerie de Gregorio del Almo: Madrid 1898.
  3. ARTIGAS, M. T. - GLICK, F. - MARTÍNEZ, R. A., Negotiation Darwin, The John Hopkins Press: Baltimore 2006.
  4. ARTIGAS, M. T. - GLICK, F. - MARTÍNEZ, R. A., "Darwin and the Vatican: The Reception of Evolutionary Theories," in ENGEL, EVE-MARIE - GLICK, THOMAS F. (eds.), The Reception of Charles Darwin in Europe I, Continuum: London - New York 2008, s. 413-429.
  5. BADIALI, FEDERICO, >>Vivere una doppia cittadinanza<<. La teologia della creazione nei quaderni de >>La Civiltà Cattolica<<, EDB: Bologna 2013.
  6. BRICARELLI, C., "Evoluzione e domma," LCC 1899.
  7. CLIFTON, MICHAEL, A Victorian Convert Quintet. Studies in the Faith of Five Leading Victorian Converts to Catholicism from the Oxford Movement, Saint Austin Press: London 1998.
  8. CONRY, YVETTE, L'introduction du darwinisme en France au XIXe siécle. J. Vrin: Paris 1974.
  9. GARDEIL, AMBROISE., "L'évolutionisme et les principes de S. Thomas." Revue Thomiste 1, 1893, s. 27-45.
  10. DUILHÉ DE SAINT-PROJET, F., Apologie Scientifique de la Foi Chrétienne, 2. ed., Libraire De la Société bibliographique Paris - Éd. Privat Toulouse 1885.
  11. DUILHÉ DE SAINT-PROJET, F., Apologie Scientifique de la Foi Chrétienne, 4. ed.. Libraire Ch. Posseilgue Rue Cassette 15 Paris - Libraire èd. Privat Rue des Tourneurs 45 - Toulouse 1897.
  12. DUILHÉ DE SAINT-PROJET, F., Apologie víry křesťanské na základě věd přírodních, PODLAHA, ANTONÍN (trsl.), Cyrillo-Methodějská knihtiskárna a Nakl. V. Kotrba: Praha 1897.
  13. GARDEIL, AMBROISE., La crédibilité et l´apologétique, Paris 1912.
  14. GARDEIL, AMBROISE., Le donée révélé et la theologie, Paris 1915.
  15. GARDEIL, AMBROISE., La structure de l´âme et l´expérience mystique 1-2, Paris 1927.
  16. GIBELLINI, R., La teologia del XX secolo, Queriniana: Brescia 1992.
  17. GRUBER, J. W., A consciousness in conflict: the life of St. George Jackson Mivart, Columbia University Press: New York 1960.
  18. GRUBER, J. W., "Mivart, George Jackson, st.," in B. L. MARTHALER (ed.), New Catholic Encyclopedia 9, Catholic University of America: Washington D.C. 2003, s. 746-747.
  19. HARVEY, JOY, "Darwin in a French Dress: Translating, Publishing and Supporting Darwin in Nineteenth-Century France." in ENGEL, EVE-MARIE - GLICK, THOMAS F. (eds.), The Reception of Charles Darwin in Europe I, Continuum: London - New York 2008, s. 354-374.
  20. CHENU, M. D., Le Saulchoir. Una Scuola di teologia, Marietti: Casale Monferrato 1937.
  21. LADOUS, R., "Le magistère catholique face au progrès scientifique (1870-1914)", in ARMOGATHE, J. R. - BLAIRE, Y. M. (eds.), Histoire générale du christianisme, PUF: Rome 2010, s. 763-788.
  22. LAMARCK, J. B. P. A., Philosophie zoologique ou exposition des considérations relatives à l´histoire naturelle des animaux I, DENT, libr. rue du Pont de Lodi: Paris 1809.
  23. LEROY, M. D., L´Évolution des espèces organiques, Libraire Accademique: Paris 1887.
  24. LEROY, M. D., L´Évolution restreinte aux espèces organiques, Delhomme et Briguet: Paris - Lyon 1891.
  25. LOBO, A. A. OP, Padre Arintero. Un domenicano all´inizio dell´opera dell´amore misericordioso, Edizioni di San Sisto Vecchio: Roma 2015.
  26. MARTÍNEZ, R. A., "The Reception of Evolutionary Theories in the Church," in AULETTA, G. -LECLERC, M. - MARTÍNEZ, R. A., Biological Evolution: Facts and Theories : a Critical Appraisal 150 Years After "The Origin of Species", Gregorian Biblical BookShop: Rome 2011, s. 589-612.
  27. MIVART, G. J. St., On the Genesis of Species, Mac Milland and co.: London 1871.
  28. MONDIN, J.-B, "Gardeil Ambroise," in J.-B. MONDIN, Dizionario dei teologi, Edizioni Studio Domenicano: Bologna 1992, s. 254.
  29. PIANCIANI, G.-B. , "Cosmogonia. Della origine a della unità della specie umana," LCC 1861, I, s. 165-187.
  30. POSPÍŠIL, C. V., "Sv. František z Assisi a evoluční vznik/stvoření člověka, aneb o báječných >>čtenářích<< knihy stvoření," in HLAVÁČEK, PETR - LIŠČÁK, VLADIMÍR - POSPÍŠIL, CTIRAD VÁCLAV AJ. (eds), Fenomén františkánství v interakci s "jinakostí", Filosofická fakulta UK - Filosofia, nakladatelství FÚ AV ČR: Praha 2016, s. 106-123.
  31. POSPÍŠIL, C. V., Zápolení o pravdu, naději a lidskou důstojnost: Český katolická teologie 1850-1950 a výzvy přírodních věd v širším světovém kontextu, Praha: Univerzita Karlova v Praze, nakladatelství Karolinum, 2017.
  32. PRANTL, F., "Vývoj české botaniky a zoologie v XIX. století," AAVV, Zdeňku Nejedlému Československá akademie věd, Nakl. ČSAV: Praha 1953, s. 477-499.
  33. RÁDL, E., Dějiny biologických teorií novověku II. Dějiny evolučních teorií v biologii 19. století, Academia: Praha 2006.
  34. TORT, PATRICK, "Bonniot, Joseph de," in TORT, P. (ed.), Dictionnaire du darwinisme et de l'évolution, Presses Universitaires de France: Paris 1996; s. 377.
  35. P. TORT, "Brücker, Joseph," in TORT, P. (ed.), Dictionnaire du darwinisme et de l'évolution, Presses Universitaires de France: Paris 1996, s. 445.